AELAQ     Current Issue     Archives     How to get mRb  
Thirty-fourth Issue
Volume 14, No. 2

..where to find the mrb

The Mrb Is Available At The Following Locations:


By Eric Boodman

The Anatomy Of Clay
By Abby Paige

They Fight Like Soldiers, They Die Like Children / Mobilizing The Will To Intervene: Leadership To Prevent Mass Atrocities
By Aparna Sanyal


Bats Or Swallows
Reviewed by Taylor Tower

Lives: Whole And Otherwise
Reviewed by Rosel Kim

Reviewed by Kimberly Bourgeois

Spat The Dummy
Reviewed by Ian McGillis

The Obituary
Reviewed by Anna Leventhal

Three Deaths
Reviewed by Rob Sherren


Bad Animals: A Father’s Accidental Education In Autism
Reviewed by Leila Marshy

Making Waves: The Continuing Portuguese Adventure
Reviewed by Joni Dufour

The Republic Of Therapy
Reviewed by Sarah Fletcher

Writing In The Time Of Nationalism: From Two Solitudes To Blue Metropolis
Reviewed by Gregory J. Reid

You Could Lose An Eye: My First 80 Years In Montreal
Reviewed by Joel Yanofsky

non-fiction at a glance

Eeyou Istchee: Land Of The Cree/terre Des Cris
Reviewed by Carol Katz

The Origin Of A Person
Reviewed by Prosenjit Dey Chaudhury


Blood Is Blood
Reviewed by Bert Almon

Hard Feelings
Reviewed by Bert Almon

Poets And Killers
Reviewed by Bert Almon

Song Of The Taxidermist
Reviewed by Bert Almon

The Collected Books Of Artie Gold
Reviewed by Bert Almon

The Truth Of Houses
Reviewed by Bert Almon

Where We Might Have Been
Reviewed by Bert Almon

the mile end café

The October Crisis, 1970 An Insider’s View/trudeau's Darkest Hour, War Measures In Time Of Peace, October 1970
Reviewed by Mélanie Grondin

the mrb cartoon

Image By Jean-philippe Marcotte

young readers

Captured: The Divided Realms Series, Book 1
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Into The Mist: The Story Of The Empress Of Ireland
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Milo: Sticky Notes And Brain Freeze
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Noni Says No
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Raffi’s New Friend
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Scaredy Squirrel Has A Birthday Party
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Today, Maybe
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Without You
Reviewed by Andrea Belcham

Writing In The Time Of Nationalism: From Two Solitudes To Blue Metropolis
Linda Leith
paper 204 pp.
Signature Edition ISBN 9781897109489

Writing in the Time of Nationalism: From Two Solitudes to Blue Metropolis
Ms. Leith, Tear Down This Wall!

Printer friendly         Send to a friend

New Document Linda Leith’s memoir, Writing in the Time of Nationalism, records her stellar career: she pioneered the teaching and researching of Anglo-Quebec writers, worked to establish QSPELL (Quebec Society for the Promotion of English-language Literature) – later the Quebec Writers’ Federation (QWF) – served as editor of Matrix magazine and various collections, wrote three novels and a number of academic papers, and undertook the organization of the cross-linguistic literary event Write pour eìcrire which ultimately led to her crowning achievement, the mammoth and much celebrated Blue Metropolis Festival. For historians and academics, Leith’s memoir will forever stand as the first single-authored monograph on the subject of Anglo-Quebec literature and a unique source of documentary evidence on the establishment of the QWF and the Blue Met. Leith’s telling, however, seems to shine less brilliantly than the historical period and events she describes. The problem is not so much the author’s modesty as her paradoxical determination to tell her story against the all-too-familiar backdrop of a myth of two solitudes.

Leith’s career – in fact, her very existence as an Anglo-Quebec author and impresario – is a contradiction of the notion that English and French live in total isolation from one another, yet Leith chooses to reify the myth by making her memoir “a story about the effect of two rival nationalisms.” Nationalism has long been the favourite whipping boy of Canadian academics and literati, so it is not terribly surprising that it plays the straw-man villain in Leith’s narrative. Nonetheless, Leith’s insistence on the binary argument stretches credibility. For example, having transformed the solitudes into “two nationalisms” and then into two cities, Montreal and Toronto, Leith then tries, against ample evidence to the contrary, to reconstruct Margaret Atwood as an icon of Toronto-centrism and, by implication, the Anglo solitude.

Leith’s broad brush strokes along the fault line of two solitudes repeatedly obliterate what might be surprising, different and compelling – not to mention more accurate. She tells the reader, for example, that “Margaret Atwood is a Canadian writer; Michel Tremblay is a Quebec writer,” followed by near-tautological though dated observations that English Canadian literature tends to be taught in university English departments, Quebec literature in French departments. What gets overwritten by these ostensibly obvious declarations is “the news” that Tremblay has recently been vilified by Queìbeìcois nationalists (Bernard Landry announced he would never again attend a Tremblay play), that Canadian literature is being taught and researched worldwide in French and English in a comparative context, and that virtually every university in Quebec offers courses on Anglo-Queìbeìcois literature these days.

Leith’s claims that the 1940s and 1950s were a “golden age” for English-language writers in Montreal, that the rise of English-Canadian nationalism caused a decline in the fortunes of Montreal’s English-language writers, that Quebec nationalism caused a further decline, and that we are currently enjoying a “revival” of the “golden age” of the 1940s and 1950s are all debatable in varying degrees. To their credit, many Anglo writers were struggling to pursue their craft during la grande noirceur in Duplessis’s Quebec. Ralph Gustafson was in New York, Richler was in Europe, Mavis Gallant had moved to Paris and was publishing in The New Yorker. As Gustafson succinctly describes the period in “Queìbec, Writing in Eng- lish” (The Oxford Companion to Canadian Literature): “English Queìbec was abroad.” What the real drama of Leith’s narrative, her confrontation with that other “solitude,” Franco-Queìbeìcois nationalism, reveals, aside from perceived slights, bureaucratic red tape, scheduling headaches, and a series of misunderstandings with Denise Boucher, author of Les feìes ont soif and then president of UNEQ (Union des eìcrivaines et des eìcrivains queìbeìcois), is Leith’s consistent essentializing of the Queìbeìcois – as if “Queìbeìcois” meant being the bearer of some immortal, homogenous, immutable essence. Her consequent vision of Anglo Quebec is explicitly not Queìbeìcois; it is a vision of a circumscribed Anglo Montreal.

Leith’s memoir follows the structure of a novel, with a buildup of conflict and tension, various reversals leading to a happy ending (the Blue Metropolis Festival), a denouement (Leith announcing her retirement), and a post-climactic, asyndetic epilogue of recent Anglo-Queìbeìcois literary successes. Ultimately, the two solitudes offer a mythic back- ground foil to the David-against- two-Goliaths story that Leith wants to tell – and Leith deserves this emblem. For once again, when no-one else dared, she has launched the discussion of Anglo-Quebec literature and a debate that will take us long into the future.

Gregory J. Reid is a Professor of English and Comparative Literature at the Universiteì de Sherbrooke.